Abner Doubleday Award 
| Abner Doubleday Award - Most Valuable Player | ||||
| Year | Crackerjack League | Peanut League | ||
| 1946 | ||||
| 1945 | ||||
| 1944 | Dixie Walker Monterey Jacks |
--Tie-- Stan Musial Dover Pilgrims Stan Spence Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1943 | Whit Wyatt Cincinnati Rhinos |
Lou Boudreau Tri-County Travelers |
||
| 1942 | Mort Cooper West Park War Eagles |
Bill Nicholson Black Oak Ridge Bombers |
||
| 1941 | Cecil Travis Cincinnati Rhinos |
Jeff Heath Black Oak Ridge Bombers |
||
| 1940 | Johnny Mize Monterey Jacks |
--Tie-- Frankie Hayes Black Oak Ridge Bombers Joe Dimaggio Altoona Warriors |
||
| 1939 | Johnny Mize Monterey Jacks |
Joe Dimaggio Altoona Warriors |
||
| 1938 | Mel Ott Asheville Smokies |
Jimmie Foxx Oak Ridge Bombers |
||
| 1937 | Charlie Gehringer Kansas City Monarchs |
Joe Medwick Laplata Tornados |
||
| 1936 | Babe Herman San Francisco Seals |
Lou Gehrig Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1935 | Augie Galan Texas Aggies |
Arky Vaughan Laplata Tornados |
||
| 1934 | Jimmie Foxx Texas Aggies |
Lou Gehrig Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1933 | Mel Ott San Francisco Seals |
Mickey Cochrane Oak Ridge Bombers |
||
| 1932 | Jimmie Foxx Texas Aggies |
Lou Gehrig Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1931 | Mel Ott San Francisco Seals |
Lou Gehrig Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1930 | Mel Ott San Francisco Seals |
Lou Gehrig Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1929 | Rogers Hornsby San Francisco Seals |
Babe Ruth San Diego Admirals |
||
| 1928 | Rogers Hornsby San Francisco Seals |
Lou Gehrig Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1927 | Paul Waner Morristown Jacks |
Babe Ruth San Diego Admirals |
||