#1 Draft Picks | Year | Player | Team |
| 1940 | Pee Wee Reese | Cincinnati Rhinos |
| 1939 | Ted Williams | Dover Pilgrims |
| 1938 | Joe Gordon | Altoona Warriors |
| 1937 | Bobby Doerr | Frisco Eagles |
| 1936 | Joe DiMaggio | Cardiff Sea Dogs |
| 1935 | Claude Passeau | San Diego Admirals |
| 1934 | Harlond Clift | Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
| 1933 | Bob Johnson | Los Angeles Shoeless Joes |
| 1932 | Arky Vaughan | Laplata Tornados |
| 1931 | Ernie Lombardi | Laplata Tornados |
| 1930 | Wally Berger | Kansas City Monarchs |
| 1929 | Earl Averill | Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
| 1928 | Carl Hubbell | San Francisco Seals |
| 1927 | Babe Ruth | San Diego Admirals |