Moonlight Graham Award 
| Moonlight Graham Award - Rookie Of The Year | ||||
| Year | Crackerjack League | Peanut League | ||
| 1946 | ||||
| 1945 | ||||
| 1944 | Ted Wilks Chicago Outlaws |
Tommy de la Cruz Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1943 | Jesse Flores D.C. Knights |
Hank Wyse Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1942 | Johnny Pesky Chesterton Slicers |
Bill Butland Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1941 | Lum Harris Goat Island Lights |
Phil Rizzuto California Tornados |
||
| 1940 | Johnny Podgajny West Park War Eagles |
Wally Judnich South Bend Silver Hawks |
||
| 1939 | Dizzy Trout Monterey Jacks |
Ted Williams Dover Pilgrims |
||
| 1938 | Enos Slaughter Maryland Skipjacks |
Johnny Rizzo Altoona Warriors |
||
| 1937 | Lou Fette Texas Aggies |
Jim Turner Oak Ridge Bombers |
||
| 1936 | Johnny Mize Monterey Jacks |
Joe DiMaggio Cardiff Sea Dogs |
||
| 1935 | Moose Solters Louisiana Krewe |
Cy Blanton Los Angeles Shoeless Joes |
||
| 1934 | Paul Dean Texas Aggies |
Hal Trosky Los Angeles Shoeless Joes |
||
| 1933 | Russ Van Atta Maryland Skipjacks |
Schoolboy Rowe Virginia Senators |
||
| 1932 | Bill Swift Texas Aggies |
Huck Betts San Diego Admirals Virginia Senators |
||
| 1931 | Ripper Collins Texas Aggies |
Buzz Arlett New Jersey Bandits/ Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1930 | Wally Berger Kansas City Monarchs |
Ben Chapman Oak Ridge Bombers |
||
| 1929 | Johnny Frederick Carolina Moonshiners |
Earl Averill Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||
| 1928 | Mel Ott San Francisco Seals |
Ed Morris Quasqueton Carpsuckers |
||